Hii guy's. I tell my experience by the blue heaven eyeliner water proof I am use this eye liner last few years this is very good for the eyes and water proof not be spread the eyes and the eyes shows very good and I advise my frends and realities this quality is very grateful and this eye liner was very very good so the eye liner is was very good so I suggest that use the blue heaven eyeliner some eye liner was use the after spread the eyes and show the as a dark circles so the greatest eye liner