I have purchase faces magnet eyes kajal before 2 weeks ago from amazon. It's an average product. Because they says that it have two uses, as eyeliner and eye kajal. It not friendly for using eyeliner but eyw kajal is better. It have thick black in colour. It not smudge proof. Not best for oily skin. It staying on eyes maximun 3-4 hours. Not long lasting. But it better than himalaya eye kajal. Affordable price. I am not fully satisfied with this product.