Your review is Submitted Successfully. ×
shre_7@shre_7
Apr 24, 2002 01:31 PM, 1406 Views
(Updated Apr 24, 2002)
Some controversial reviews

I might not be a very popular member of Mouthshut, but have been noticed a few reviews which need to be talked about.


1) loverboy4u_17’s review( Some Suggestions.) - This was a highly contreversial review as the comments showed. The suggestions given there were pretty good, though loverboy could have avoided the forceful language. The comment by caretaker was pretty out of place but the comment by anishsh was pretty good. I wonder why not much discussion went into that. I guess he got intimitaded by loverboy’s comment. But really I think that the comment by anishsh was partly correct and holds particularly good for loverboy and some Star Writers. But don’t get me wrong, I have nothing against loverboy, if you notice he is on my trust list.


2)Sujay_marthi’s review(Mumbai) - Well I guess I have to be a bit frank here. But how did a writer as classy as Sujay_marthi write such a review. It was in my opinion a’publicity gathering’ opinion by Sujay_marthi and it did it’s job with all the naive members commenting on it. Forgive me, but I just speak my mind. Star Writer’s like him should not stoop so low and they should be a role model and write reviews which are worthy of thier status


3)Asyis and Amrita’s review on B’lore- These two reviews lead to a member’reviewer’ being flagged for the case of member harrasment. This is complete injustice. I can give you more examples were such personal exchanges took place and the members were left scot free. Check out Sanyogeeta’s review and Imran’s review. You will find many such personal exchanges there.


Well these are my genreral thoughts and I just did what I had to. I am sorry if I offended anyone.

(13)
VIEW MORE
Please fill in a comment to justify your rating for this review.
Post

Recommended Top Articles

Question & Answer