This herbal kajal is smooth and very black. But after reusing it many times it doesn’t stay pointed which we need to make a sharp straight stroke on the lower waterline. It also stings the eyes. You feel like just rub off the kajal because of its stinginess. It smells like camphor a bit as it is herbal. Otherwise it is smooth to apply and gives out good black colour. It doesn’t stay for long. And it smuges a lot. Your whole eye area surrounds by that black kajal. Not a very bad product but at the same time not a product worth to buy.