I used this kajal for like a year and was happy with its quality but after that it started to smudge I wasn’t sure if the product quality got changed I even had problems while applying it on my eyes.at first when I started to use it it would get applied in a single stroke or two after that now that I use it I have to apply it for 3 4 to four strokes to get that look and I don’t even last longer now.I’m disappointed how the product quality changed or it might didn’t worked on me.