It was the first liner I have ever used.i just love everything about this liner except the fact that it takes really long to dry and thats the only minus point with this liner.otherwise it is very much comparable to other liners of range 600-700.it is super black and after it dries it give u a smoth finish.easy to apply.very nyc to be used as a winged liner.it comes with a very thin applicator which is again a very good point.i have been using it since last 10 years and een after using a lot of eye liner product it is my top favourite.love it