Yes its a good liner with great rich colour and softness , . Well I too was a regular user of this eye liner . This liner concludes that its a water proof one , but no its all fake after applying and dry eyeliner when sweat or water strucks over your liner the liner gets messy and spread all over . And the worst thing about liquid liners are they donot get dry easily . Whenever I use the liner I often leave my eye messy if not after sometime due to water or sweat it gets messy of its own . If you wear this liner for long time with the design of enlongated wings after 6-7 hours you will find no wings behind your eyes how those wings will wash down you too van’t even know . If you people seriously need a good liner then buy lakmé 9-5 insta eye liner . It has got sketch type handeling and will keep your liner stay for long . Good luck fellas