I like most of the lakme products as suit my indian skin tone and type well, but some how I did not like this eyeliner much. this eyeliner did not fair on my oily eyelids. application wand and brush tip of this eyeliner is too small and it becomes difficult to apply it in a good definition on the eyelids. it takes lot of time to apply the eyeliner precisely onto the eyelids. more over it becomes lumpy on the eyelids if the wheather is humid. it is not a waterproof eyeliner. so if you sweat, then it spreads crazy all around your eyes