After reading some of the comments regarding an alleged ’’Shrek’’/’’Monsters, Inc. rivalry, I simply want to conclude that I enjoyed both heartily (bought the ’’Shrek’’ DVD yesterday, will definitely purchase the ’’Monsters, Inc.’’ DVD) and that both are highly accomplished animated features. On the ’’Ebert and Roeper’’ TV show, critic Richard Roeper somewhat dismissed the film as something the kids would enjoy, but something where the adults would be glancing at their watches every few minutes. I can assure Mr. Roeper that my eyes did not stray ONCE during the film; the poor fellow must be jaded by so-called sophisticated movies.
I will not rehash the plot. I will say that all elements that constitute a movie, from background to characterization, were dazzling, convincing, and comprehensive. Monstropolis emerges as a fully fleshed out dimension uncannily mirroring our own - even up to the minute, with the simultaneously uproarious but sobering scene where a monster returns from the human dimension with a child’s sock stuck to his back and he is manhandled (monster-handled) by decontamination crew members. Mike Waslowski (Billy Crystal) and James P. (’’Sully’’) Sullivan (Goodman) move easily through this world. While the ’’Odd Couple’’ pairing is obviously not new (as admittedly, the plot - BUT WHO CARES?), Crystal and Goodman add spicy spin to their camaraderie. Despite Crystal’s comedic presence, Goodman anchors this movie with his hulking and massive but ultimately sensitive and caring character, well, at least a good part of the time. Boo gives Sully a run for his money in the presence department.
Despite superficial plot similarities to Toy Story (especially in the climactic dimensional door pursuit - yes, a potential Disney theme ride) and yes, even a smidgen of ’’King Kong), ’’Monsters, Inc.’’ stands on its own as a fascinating, well-rendered, multi-faceted piece of work. It is NOT a sickeningly cloying, sweet movie. Its moments of tenderness are balanced with some unsettling moments (e.g., Sully’s scare demonstration (scared me, too) which terrifies Boo, Boo’s restraint in the ’’Scream Suction’’ device by the nefarious, reptilian Randall, and Sully’s/Randall’s fight, where Sully is being strangled by his invisible enemy). Sully’s and Boo’s developing relationship mixed in both laughter and tears The dialogue and presence of the supporting characters was natural, matter-of-fact, and all the more funny for it.
In short, ’’Monster, Inc.’’’s plan came wonderfully together. Unlike some commentators, the movie DOES have messages, not only of love and devotion and self-acceptance, but also about having the courage to risk altering a lifetime of conditioned thinking and behavior when it proves to be misguided. Pixar, you’ve done it again. Keep doing it...please! ’’Monsters, Inc.
One quibble: Boo spends a considerable amount of time in the Monstropolis dimension. I wonder what her parents were thinking when she was missing. Perhaps the Monstropolis dimension is on a different time line, where hours there are the equivalent of minutes in our dimension (time relativity and all).
Out of 5 stars, I would rate ’’Monsters, Inc.’’ 4 1/2 stars(a slight demerit to familiarity of plot, but again, WHO CARES?) Rejuvenate heart, body, and soul. See this movie!