We get two eyeliner in this pack. one is gel based and the other powder based cake. the gel eueliner that comes in this packing is too good, its pigmentation is moderately dark which is good on daily basis and is long lasting. but the powder cake ruins your makeup when worn. it transfers so badly on to every part of your face from tje eyelids. I even tried make it work by spraying water etc onto application brush but it did not work. so the gel eyeliner is the only good product that comes in this packaging