Note: Review is a bit long and includes comparison with other brands. Let me give a short background about how I discovered this brand before I go ahead and review it so that it would be helpful for others who might have faced similar issues. I have what you could say more than the average size feet for an Indian girl so it is almost impossible for me to find shoes in my size (UK8/US10/Euro 41) in India. Then came my lifesaver namely myntra.com.
I was finally able to get shoes in my size and in such a convenient hassle-free way too :) Their size guide is amazing as it gives the size in all variants (US/UK/Euro) and also in centimetres in addition to that. Till date, every pair of shoes I have ordered from there has fit me perfectly with the exception of one which I sent back and the amount was promptly refunded back into my account (by default they refund it as Mynt Credits but if you call them and say that you want it reversed in your credit card/bank account, they would do that).
So in my experience, I discovered that I am able to find shoes in my size only in these 4 brands - Catwalk, Carlton London, Inc.5 and Rocia. And out of all these, I can honestly say Inc.5 is the best among those in terms of comfort and feel. I have not used them extensively so I cannot comment on the durability but I don’t have any doubts about that. But I would not recommend them for rough use.
In comparison, Catwalk is quite durable and long lasting and feels solid. I have stepped into numerous puddles in my Catwalk shoes and they are still fine (knock on wood). But when it comes to comfort, Inc.5 takes the title as the soles of most Catwalk footwear seem a bit hard whereas most of Inc.5 shoes are cushioned so it’s comfortable. Carlton London and Rocia are fine for short term wear because after a couple of hours, your feet might start aching.
Raw Hide is another brand where you might be able to find shoes in your size if you have big sized feet like me but their models are pretty basic and not very girly so I haven’t included that.