For Me: This liner is Toohhh Good as I can wash it or remove it, if the liner is not the same I want to. Because m also a beautician and I used this for my practice in My learning days and I use it still also. Because it will not harm to my eyes untill I tried for serval Times????.
I also Use the other One lines the pencil one but I am not satisfied with them nd the waterproof liner is to dam bad for me, if done a singlr line its hard to remove it without harm my eye so perfer it for new girls eho trying it or thing to use liner. But one more thing its just not a low product if you through the water in face after applying it. It will not spread untill you remove it by your Hand.