My personnel experience with Elle 18 Lip Make up has been very bad, its very oily and you never get the color that you see on the shade card not matter its a light shade or dark when you apply it does not give you the promised color it simply makes you lips look oily looks like you have used a very cheap type of lip balm, it does not even compare to the standard lip balm so its a waste of money it can neither be used as a lip balm nor a lipstic.