I am start useing garnier men oil clear face was from 3-4 year ago. I am very happy with this product because best face was for men and specially for oily skin care. last 3 month ago I am buy this product again and I am noticed product quality was change, difference was thikness and after I am use this product my face was completely clear but now I am notice product quality not maintain because not not so effective then older one. I am very dis-pointed with garnier because if product was good so why change it.