I was just looking at some of the last reviews and bumped across this review and spent some time at this site.
What a terrific concept. I have never seen anything quite like it. So at the end no analysis or data, its all about gut.
I think even 20 times a day I use this word gutfeel and never got a chance to express it so publicly. The best part I like about the concept is that anybody can challenge the thoughts/views expressed on the site. Moreover, one can also post their article and have discussion around the same.
The content is relevant and fresh. I think freshness is from the diverse people who are sharing their gut feelings.
I think success of this concept lies in focuss. I hope webmaster will be going more for quality than quantity. If they are going to do so, this site will rock. Essentially it should be for class not for mass.