I purchased this product long time back but was not satisfied with it. It is not waterproof and smudgeproof. I had to be very cousious everytime I applied it. Is dosen’t stay on the lids for a long time and you have to reapply it. It gives a very dull look and irritates the eye sometimes in my case its even worse. My lids swells up if I apply this liner. The bottle is too small and the cost is high if compared to the size. It has only 3.5 ml of liquud in it. And you might even get other in this range. It dries out super fast so you need to take extra care of the bottle. The bristles of the brush is quite thick so you might even face problem in applying a thin line. I would not like to buy it in near future. Thank you.