I have been using lakme 9 to 5 eyeliner since 1 year occassionaly and I find it really magical.it shines like a glitters compare to other eyeliners and one thing it doesn’t mess if I rub my eyes though I forget sometimes that I have put on eyeliner in my eyes???? it stay so frequent that it just look like I have put it just now.i just loved the product and I recommend all the girls out here to use it too.it gives blends to your eyes gives mesmerizing looks.u can find attractive look of your eyes even though u pour water or I got wet on rain it doesn’t get mess.