I’m not very happy with Lakme black impact liner because I have one and it’s response is not that good . When it was new I was very happy and I was in love with this eye liner, I loved it above all of my liners, it was like just one strock liner and it stay on eye for a very good time and also is smug proof and the texture was perfectly mat black and I love mat on my eye. It was such a good product that I recomended it to my mom’s also , but after using fewer or more than that time it start getting dry and the brush of it is expanded now and I hate it like hell. I don’t know why the product has truned into this but it’s happend with my liner as well as with my mom’s liner