Who said it is smudge proof .when ever I applied it it really smudged .and maked my eyes so blacky like I have dark circles.it really not suits me.totally drama.my frnds also use it but they also experienced bad now they all now not using it and m also tooo.now if we see at any fare or open markets people are selling even this duplicate kajal at same price .how could we know that which kajal is origional kajal.if u people frnds agree with this than pls do ans me ?