I have mixed feelings for this product as I like it as well as dislike it. There is one friend of mine who used it and I use to love her eye makeup and finally I asked that whuch liner she uses. I bought it and start to use it and till now this is the only kajal that stays on my eyes without smudging. I have used many liners but this one is best. I also use it as kajal more than liner. It gives my eyes an deep intense look.