I was just a begginer.! So I bought this! It was Not bad though! Itz Affordable too! . Water resistant ! .but it does not give dark fine colour wen we swipe our colossal kajal just once.thtz the only con of this product.! With 2 or 3 swipes.we are good too gooo! . It doesnt make our waterline look too odd .it gives the perfect look.nd though the product claims tht I would stay fr 5 hrs max.it doesnt.it hardly stays fr maz 3 hrs.then u gotto swipe again.to hav a cool look.thtz it! Overall.not bad. Nd yeah it doesnt smudge ??