I love it It’s an above average product.it gives a nice dark black color and its creamy and retractable and it lasts a good amount of hours but unfortunately it budges on my lower eyelid and I find it works better on top of my upper eyelids than in the waterline
Will not repurchase.I’d rather try a new one
I love this eyeliner! 1. It’s cheap 2. It doesn’t smudge even when tight lining and water lining my eyes 3. It lasts all day 4. It’s a retractable pencil(always a plus for me) 5. It’s yellow so it’s easy to spot! I just love this eyeliner! Even my Mac kohl eyeliner and my Marc Jacobs eyeliner can’t compare to this. Love love LOVE IT!