Hello friends .i disscuss my opinion with you on maybelline new york eyeliner .friends I am used this eyeliner last 6month.it is very easy to use and I used it daily.it shaded darker. I prefer this eyeliner as compare to other.it is easily available on all online shopping websites and our locally market.it is not very costly. its worked long time in days . this eyeliner is water proof. I love this eyeliner and I suggested all my friends purchased it and use it.this product is very useful to Makeover ourselves .