The fact that it is a herbal kajal was a mere attraction for me to buy this product but when I used it I hated it. the one thing we need from a kajal is to stay and not smudge but after not even an hour of applying this product it just started smudging ansd after a few more hours poeple came to ask me for why I had black eye . it was horrandious to look at myself in the mirror after that, its a complete no no for anyone who needs a pigmented smudge free kajal dont go for this one.