I got this Patanjali herbal kajal few months back.as nowadays everyone is switching to herbal products and Patanjali is a leading most used brand.About this herbal kajal. Pros- Its dark kajal. One stroke is good to go. Good to eyes. no itching or redness. Cons- Application is pretty hard sometimes. Smudges very easily.within an hour. After removing it does not come off all over.it leaves blackish lower lids area and for me it remained for a day. >So for me it didnt worked.although its less priced and Patanjali labelled herbal product still it cant meet with the quality and finish of cosmetic brands.