In my opinion it is below average. The biggest problem with this products is that it smudges so badly that part around your eye becomes awful.Moreover it does not last long in your eyes.
The good part is that it is herbal . As I dont stay without kajal so when I am at home I use this product but when I have to go outside I wash my face and use smudge free kajal. I cant use it with makeup on as I am sure that it will spoil my eye makeup too.