Home > sheermelody's Profile
Report this member
Alert on new posting by this member
This is your modal content. Add any elements you need here.
Karnataka
Member Since:Jan 24, 2005
0 MS Points
You are better off not knowing me. :). Music, literature, and movies
About Me
Education: B Tech
Rewards
Review of the Day (0)
Featured Article (0)
Go for Guru
3
Reviewed Guru (2007)
Before the long weekend, here’s yet another review on a movie which I distinctly enjoyed in parts. Guru is a simple movie, the second half of which makes youRead more...
Just about passable
2
Reviewed Honeymoon Travels Pvt Ltd
Good movies are all alike, bad movies are bad in their own special way. Honeymoon Travels is not a good movie at all; compared to the tripe that Bollywood disRead more...
Painfully bad
1
Reviewed Nishabd
Perhaps what is more deplorable than some of the movies which Bollywood frequently churns out is the sheer number of people who actually go and watch the trasRead more...
Engaging
4
Reviewed Namesake
The Namesake is an interesting movie. It is not a great movie, but it’s a good one. Adaptations of books into movies have never been easy, and rarely has it bRead more...
The dockside
Reviewed Red - Bollywood
Red – the dark side is, quite expectedly, Vikram Bhatt’s tribute to crass, unworthy and unwatchable cinema. As the movie progresses, you realize how bad an idRead more...
Refreshingly different in parts
Reviewed Eklavya: The Royal Guard
After a long hiatus, I am back to writing reviews. And what better to start with than the ferociously advertised Eklavya – the royal guard. The movie is a sucRead more...
Grotesque filmmaking at its best
Reviewed Apocalypto Movie
I hated this movie. Hated it because it was a shoddy attempt at making a film which is supposed to matter – in some curious, lopsided way. There is no doubt tRead more...
The greatest composers in India
Reviewed Ten Best Hindi Music Directors
Creating a list of ten music directors is not without it pitfalls. Because, very soon you realize that it would be more interesting if you could rank them as Read more...
Absolutely sublime
5
Reviewed Aparajito
For a person who watched the second movie of the trilogy before the first, Pather Panchali, *watching Aparajito was an amazing and path-breaking experience. ORead more...
The death of poetry
Reviewed Twenty Worst English Songs
Deciding upon the worst songs ever is tough as it is potentially inflammatory. There is always chance of comments appearing out of nowhere on your review, jusRead more...
How Johnny Cash became Johnny Cash
Reviewed Walk the Line
Walk the line is a sweet, meandering biopic on the darkness of Johnny Cash’s life, a man who was never as simple as he looked. Starkly different from the brutRead more...
A look at the year gone by
Reviewed Ten Best Bollywood Movies of 2006
If one looks at the releases from Bollywood in the year 2006, one would be surprised to see a surprising number of rather well-made movies, which proves two tRead more...
The weekend review on favorites...
Reviewed Twenty Best English Songs
It’s that time of the week when you post something on your favorites, and if you are exceptionally bored, post something which requires a fair amount of thinkRead more...
Weighed down by over-expectation
Reviewed Yun Hota Toh Kya Hota
Given that Naseeruddin Shah is such a fine actor, and has directed awesome plays over the many years of his chequered career, Yun Hota to Kya Hota, his directRead more...
Below expectations
Reviewed Corporate
I finished watching Corporate. And immediately I realized that if someone from an engg. college would have written a movie script on a similar theme,he would Read more...
Coming of age
Reviewed Black Friday Songs
With the album Black Friday, Indian Ocean has finally come of age. I remember the first time I watched them perform at our college, astounded at their technicRead more...
A few personal favorites
Reviewed Twenty Best Hindi Songs
Choosing a meager twenty songs as your favorites out of the vast treasure trove of Hindi Film Music(HFM) is a humongous task. But since I have nothing much toRead more...
Satire and humor at its rawest
Reviewed English August - Upmanyu Chaterjee
This is one of the funniest books I have ever read. And probably the best attempt at humorous and mind-bending satire by an Indian author. It all starts with Read more...
A powerful film on a weather-beaten topic
Reviewed The Pianist
A somewhat late review on a wonderful film. The Pianist, released in 2002, is a magnificent movie, and by far, Polanski’s most polished and personal work. PoRead more...
Could have been better
Reviewed Saw
Saw is one overhyped movie. And although there is a lot of stuff to get really scared about in this film, the scariest is the acting.Whats painful aboutRead more...
CHANDRAKALLA AND HENIA IS DOING SCAM IN KORMANGAL
Reviewed Kaya Skin Clinic - Koramangala - Bangalore
Hello, SCAM IS RUNNING IN KAYA KORMANGALA CHANDRAKALLA AND HENIA are the part of it. Its my worst experience I had in Kaya Kormangala. While selling Read more...
@khulamunh
@maaz_nawaz
@countme91
@GEETA1963
@chalojai
Commented on own review
It's my opinion. I am not writing a research paper that I need to give links citing accurate sources to Mayan civilization and its beliefs. I never professed myself an expert in Mayan culture. I have a decent knowledge of Mayan culture and what I saw was clear degradation of what they professed/prac Read More...
I did not choose my songs based on singers. I chose them on the basis of their music. I am sorry your 'great' Rafi did not figure in this list. If this was a review of the great singers of bollywood, he would definitely have figured. I appreciate comments, but not those which are made withou Read More...
Yes, it's quite possible to disagree with me on the second half because I rather had a feeling that what the movie promised in the first half in terms of story-telling was lost in the speech and the ending scenes. The reason for me not liking Meenu as a separate character just to show Guru's sof Read More...
Thank you for the comment. Please keep visiting and commenting.
As I said in the movie, this is not a bad movie. I felt the movie degenerated into typical bollywood melodrama in several parts in the second half of the movie. And the fact is that I appreciated the fact that the Guru is shown in a negative light; but all said and done, the speech in the end was do Read More...
Do see the movie, it's worth at least two dekkos.
The ending killed the movie, in my opinion. Thanks for commenting.
Yes, you echo my thoughts exactly... Yes, I too loved the movie, but not as a classic.
Yes, I expected this comment after Sanjoy told me about his disagreements. As I told MZ, I am really not sure if it's a guy thing, but yes, I didn't find the gay angle probable, although I am not very sure if such things happen or Don't happen. Well, again, one should just tell Mr. Rampal, Ms. P Read More...
Well, I am not sure if it's a guy thing to find it offensive that a gay husband was NOT happy with his marriage. But yes, I didn't find the movie as entertaining as it should have been. :)
Rated on anuraag_chandra's review
Commented on anuraag_chandra's review
I think yours is one of the most honest reviews on Namesake I have read so far. Kudos to you.
Thanks for the comment. KK is a terrific actor and I do agree that their dialogues are much better than what the rest of the film offers. Yes, if you don't care for logic and are OK with century-old views on homosexuality, it's kinda OK :)
Thank you for your comments. It's not a terribly bad movie as the review would suggest, but not good value for money either
Followed indian1969
indian1969
Rated on indian1969's review
Commented on indian1969's review
Salil-da has been sort of a mentor in my musical career, and it's refreshing to see people writing with a passion about this forgotten genius. Interestingly though, most of your opinion on Salil is formulated on his Hindi numbers. Salil-da's Bengali compositions are in a very different mould alt Read More...
Commented on drraj5555's review
I wish you guys wouldn't act holier than thou and present Chappell as the messiah for Indian cricket. His job was to coach the team well, which he failed in, and thankfully he has realized that failures lead to heads rolling... Secondly, Chappell said before the world cup: 'I am happy with the te Read More...
Sandipan Ghosh (@sandipanMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 30
Send Message
Sandeep Choudhary (@BookishMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 39
Me ... (@doveyeMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 7
Psyxx x (@psyxxMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 178
Ratnakar S (@indian1969MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 408
- - (@pri20MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 59
Shanti P (@The_ReviewerMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 43
Jodi Hayes (@jodihayesMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 93
abha atitkar jain (@amateurabeMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 60
XXX XXXXX (@patenik2MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 112
jeevananthan velayutham (@ajayanMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 46
Aruna T (@moviezombieMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 99
m s (@magicalsummerMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 55
meghala nair (@meg_nairMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 8
Parnil Urdhwareshe (@ParnilMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 58
Anton S (@sourrayMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 94
Sharath Chandra (@sharath40MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 29
f e (@flyingelephantMouthShut Verified Member)
Soma Karamjee (@somakaramjeeMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 20
Rittii Kapur (@ritiuppal2000MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 3
Unfollow Follow Send Message
Sara (@sarruu0332MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 21
Manish Singh (@Manish199MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 6
Ruchi Kumar (@SleepwellMouthShut Verified Member)
Leslie Mendez (@LesmenMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 18
Pravash Pujari (@pravashpujariMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 1
Ravi Prakash (@ravisw82MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 2
Jemal Kemal (Jemal Kemal Hassen) (@jemalkemal805MouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 0
Malavika Mallya (@mediassistMouthShut Verified Member)
Krishna Kant Bhatt (@go4worldbusinessMouthShut Verified Member)
Sahi Ram Kaswan (@jasahiramMouthShut Verified Member)
Reviews: 54
Poonam Nandani (@goibibo_ibiboMouthShut Verified Member)
Akhil Gupta (@nobrokerMouthShut Verified Member)
Anuj Sharma (@biggi15MouthShut Verified Member)
PawanAshar (@PawanAsharMouthShut Verified Member)
Pratik Gandhi (@pgandhi38MouthShut Verified Member)
Khairul Mallick (@KhairulMMouthShut Verified Member)
Ala Rahi Restoran (@alarahitrMouthShut Verified Member)
Rajesh Puri (@EduPristine_CareMouthShut Verified Member)
Arvind Gupta (@Arvind1961MouthShut Verified Member)